Refutation of al-Qaradawi
1st: Allah possesses purchased Muslims approach justly with non-Muslims also to getting sort in their eyes in accordance with the verse in the Quran:
a€?Allah doesn’t prohibit anyone to offer justly and kindly with folks that battled perhaps not against upon account of religion and decided not to travel your from your house. Verily, Allah adore people who target value.a€? ( al-Mumtahina : 8)
By pointing out this verse, al-Qaradawi statements it is authorized to congratulate non-Muslims on their vacations since this constitutes becoming kinds and just with them. But to attract this realization with this verse is definitely a mistake because are sorts and merely to many is certainly not permissible in the event it includes disobedience to Allah. Due to the fact Prophet i·? claimed: a€?There is no obedience to virtually person if it entails sin; behavior is just in the that is correct and proper.a€? 2 In this case, you will find obvious disobedience to Allah when non-Muslims dedicate act of shirk and sin as well as the Muslim congratulates these people on those times by which those acts become devoted.
Second: The Prophet i·? ordered Asmaa€™ bint Abi Bakr, as soon as the girl polytheist mom come and went to their, by saying: a€?Keep close relationships with the woman.a€? 3 once more, this really is a hadith that’s `amm (general) and mutlaq (total), thus, they claims almost nothing about family vacations. Moreover, really a credit card applicatoin of a€?behave along with them on earth kindly.a€? To utilize this verse to mean really allowable to congratulate and/or partake in non-Muslim vacation trips will be contrary to other Islamic texts, for instance as soon as Allah bought us never to listen to all of our mom and dad as long as they get people to commit serves of shirk or other sins:
a€?But in the case these people struggle along with you to help you participate in worship beside me other individuals that of that you’ve no information, subsequently observe these people perhaps not, but behave with these people around kindly.a€? (Luqman: 15).
In enumerating the reason for the versea€™s insight, the students of tafsir mentioned it absolutely was expose in the case of Saa€?ad ibn Abi Waqas, whoever mummy purchased him to observe the lady and disbelieve in Islam. Upon this, Allah revealed the above mentioned verse purchasing every believers to become acquiescent for their mom except in the case that complex disbelief or shirk. 4
One-third: Yes, Allah possess enabled Muslims to enjoy from protein of people for the e-book and marry of their womenfolk. The issue is: If a Muslim marries this sort of a woman, after that how would it is feasible for him to reside in peace, serenity, and really like along with her without congratulating the girl or the girl families on the holiday season? This style of qiyas (analogical sense) was flawed since one of the main pillars of qiyas is missing, and that is certainly the a€?illah (operative influence). 5 The a€?illah however will be the Jews and the Christians has a Divine Scripture, which involves that Muslims can consume off their meats and marry from. However, it will never be permissible for everyone to help qiyas in this particular considering that the judgment is definitely khass (specific) or muqayyad (restricted) to simply both these act. Various principles to make an allegorical presentation (taa€™wil) would be that khass and muqayyad are certainly not open for additional perceptions. 6 Also, qiyas can’t getting view web site as loaded with influence given that the certain evidences or ijmaa€?. This simply means about the outcome of qiyas need to be in conformation utilizing the objectives belonging to the Sharia€?a to find out the consistency utilizing the Islamic texts. 7 along with the truth of congratulating and indulging for the vacations regarding the non-Muslims, an ijmaa€? has become claimed on their ban by students including Ibn al-Qayyim, ergo, render this qiyas incorrect.
Next: al-Qaradawi likewise noted that the verse in which Allah says, a€?When you are met with a welcoming, greet reciprocally with what defeats they, or (at any rate) send it back just as.a€? (al-Nisaa€™: 86). Again, use of verses from Quran for uses aside from what they are created for within their situation is definitely a flawed methodology. This verse happens to be certain into the salutation definitely common amongst Muslims, and is saying salam a€?alaykum or understanding similar to it. When discussing this verse, every scholars of tafsir suggest they relating to mentioning salam a€?alaykum, and do not require lasted normal that include all kinds of greetings. 8
Abdullah bin Bayyah/Hamza Yusuf
Trash Bayyah 14 with his reserve, Sinaa€?at al-Fatwa wa Fiqh al-Aqalliyyat, quotes exactly the same proofs and axioms as al-Qaraa??awi, but the guy brings the subsequent comments:
The Scholars has disagreed upon this problem of congratulating the non-Muslims (on their fests). For the madhhab of Imam Ahmad you’ll find three belief: a) actually prohibited, b) truly disliked and c) truly permissible. It is this finally thoughts (of permissibility) that Sheikh Taqi al-Din Ibn Taymiyyah decided due to its maslaa??ah (overall close) and this is the viewpoint which pick nicely. Thus, it is permissible to congratulate these people (non-Muslims), to console them to their suffering, so you can browse their unique unwell. Al-Mardawi offers estimated a few of these narrations in his publication, al-Ina??af. And what’s talked about in a number of of this other products regarding Ibn Taymiyyah may not be in deal along with his verified belief. 15